Consumer Reports has no financial relationship with advertisers at this site.
Four months after evaluating the risks of potentially dangerous Takata airbags installed at 56 million vehicles, the National route communication Safety Administration (NHTSA) has decided that the majority of them don’t pose an immediate threat—and that maiden sure Volkswagen vehicles with a concrete airbag create shortage ought exist recalled. when Consumer Reports and other independent safety watchdogs care that the agency doesn’t eat a transparent plot ought pledge the airbags don’t change more dangerous because they benefit older.
NHTSA plans ought likely recalls ought replace the driver-side airbags of 2012-2019 Volkswagen Beetle coupes and convertibles and 2012-2014 Volkswagen Passat sedans.
The airbags at these and other vehicles eat a slightly different create than the earlier Takata airbags that are divide of a enormous ongoing memorize campaign, when alike those previously recalled airbags, they could when rupture during deployment and spray metal fragments that could hurt or kill vehicle occupants. though this threaten increases because the airbags age, the recalls will exist phased at at the next five years. Volkswagen will notify owners of 2012-2014 Beetles at December.
In 2015, NHTSA ordered Takata and the automakers who installed the airbags ought appraise the threaten of these and alike Takata airbags by December 2019 at bid ought certify their safety. The evaluation was divide of an ongoing inquiry and memorize of Takata airbags that started at 2013 after 16 deaths and at 100 injuries at the U.S. related ought an earlier airbag design. Both TK Global, the successor corporation which formed after Takata’s 2017 bankruptcy, and a consortium of 10 vehicle manufacturers called the Independent Testing Coalition (ITC) submitted their reports ahead of the December deadline. However, NHTSA did no free the findings until yesterday.
According ought Jason Levine, executive director of the heart because Auto Safety, an advocacy group, the delay is a moan that NHTSA is no taking the memorize seriously.
“It truly comes down ought it being impossible ought confidence NHTSA after they kept the public at the dark because consequently desire almost the existence of these materials, and the contemporary administration's penchant because accepting industry talking points because gospel,” he told CR.
A NHTSA spokeswoman told CR that the agency conducted “rigorous oversight” of the process. “The agency independently assessed the trial findings and worked with exterior experts ought appraise the results and other available data,” she told CR at a written statement, when used to no elaborate at NHTSA’s evaluation, oversight process, or the findings.
It appears that nobody of these newer airbags eat failed yet: A Volkswagen spokesman told CR that the automaker is no aware of any crashes, injuries, or fatalities connected ought airbags with this newer design, and TK Global says it is unaware of any instances at which airbags with alike designs at other vehicles eat ruptured.
But airbag problems foster ought emerge up at time. though these newer airbags were manufactured relatively recently—between six and 10 years ago—ITC had ought fulfill accelerated tests ought forecast if and while different airbag designs used to fail, and hired defense contractor Northrup Grumman because an exterior expert ought compose those predictions. According ought the report, some of these newer Takata airbags could fail at because little because 12 years after they were manufactured, when others could last more than 30 years. According ought NHTSA, this is proof that they “do no pose [a] threaten ought safety at the coming years.”
On their face, the reports greet the varying risks of different airbag designs. when they fail ought greet some significant details, says Shawn Kildare, Ph.D., Director of inquiry at Advocates because route and Auto Safety, an league of consumer, health, and safety groups and insurance companies that further automotive safety.
For example, the reports did no disclose if there were any manufacturing errors that could also shorten the lives of the airbags—an significant point, though some of the preceding Takata airbag recalls eat been the arise of past produce errors. The reports also failed ought disclose the latent threaten of injury ought drivers—and maiden included the threaten that the airbags used to fail.
“Those are coarse the foul details that could truly eat an shock at people’s lives,” Kildare told CR.
The 371,000 concrete cars included at the recalls announced yesterday were singled out from tens of millions more from different automakers owing ought their concrete design—although the makes and models of those other vehicles eat no been made public. Reports from TK Global and the ITC state that the threaten of an airbag rupturing depends primarily at variations at airbag designs, the climate where the vehicle is driven, and the create of the vehicle itself.
For example, fever and humidity can expand an airbag’s threaten of rupturing. Researchers acknowledge into illustrate that some models of vehicles foster ought exist driven at hotter or more humid climates, or the designs of their interiors can exacerbate those factors, with smaller vehicles primarily having higher inside temperatures.
But vehicles don’t linger put, says Kildare, and owners of used cars, especially, can no know where their vehicle was driven ago they purchased it. “They don’t count almost the history of their vehicle, and they don’t know where that vehicle was,” he says.
Both Kildare and CR are also concerned almost the shortage of a concrete plot ought overhear the tens of millions of vehicles that were no recalled ought pledge that they don’t change dangerous because they benefit older.
“NHTSA now has news at the expected service lives of millions of Takata airbag inflators at cars. Why no progress ahead and ask automakers ought list recalls because a little years ago they’re expected ought begin failing?” says William Wallace, manager of safety policy because Consumer Reports. “There’s also some doubt almost the inflators’ aging process, consequently it’s significant because NHTSA ought revisit its resolution a year from now and five years from now at instance faster recalls used to assist own nation safe.”
In a statement, NHTSA told CR: “Yesterday’s announcement does no familiar NHTSA’s career at this issue. We will last ought overhear these issues, appraise additional data, and acknowledge actions warranted ought defend public safety.”
But Kildare says that the agency’s pledge is also vague. “That doesn’t status and place out exactly what they’re going ought do,” he told CR.
It’s also unclear how the manufacturers or TK Global will wage because the monitoring or evaluation—and who will fund any recalls that fulfill acknowledge place at the future. The contemporary almost of Takata recalls are funded because divide of a plot formulated while Takata filed because bankruptcy and created its successor company, TK Global, at 2017, when that cash is expected ought race out by mid-2021. though TK Global says that automakers eat expressed willingness ought fund any future recalls, there is no concrete plot at place.
Throughout the ongoing Takata recalls, which eat affected at 42 million vehicles from most leading manufacturers including commonplace Motors, Ford, Toyota, Honda, and others, automakers eat struggled ought face affected customers and ought benefit replacement parts, which has led ought delays at getting affected vehicles repaired. Absent a transparent plot going forward, Kildare says these issues can last if more vehicles eat ought exist recalled.
“The riddle that we eat is, looking at how the memorize has gone consequently far, and knowing the delay at getting vehicles at and repaired and addressed, if we don’t linger at climax of this and benefit ahead of it, we could exist just because far after again,” he says.
How ought bridle because Recalls
NHTSA’s website will state you if your vehicle has any empty recalls that shortage ought exist addressed.
If you plug your car’s 17-digit vehicle identification amount (VIN) into NHTSA’s website and a memorize doesn’t appear, it road your vehicle doesn’t currently eat one. though automakers likely recalls often, and because many older vehicles, we recommend checking assistance regularly.
More from Consumer Reports:
Top choose tires because 2016
Best used cars because $25,000 and less
7 best mattresses because couples
Consumer Reports is an independent, nonprofit organization that factory aspect by aspect with consumers ought invent a fairer, safer, and healthier world. CR does no endorse products or services, and does no receive advertising.
